Chamaco, on Aug 10 2005, 06:49 AM, said:
Quote
Perhaps, in theory, I don't know...
But in practice, are you really sure ?
I agree that it makes sense to use wjs *after opps overcall*, but -honestly -how many times was it useful to you *when opps were silent* ?
I also like to preempt, but I found out that the frequency was too low, mostly because too many hands were TOO STRONG for a wjs (= using a wjs with those hands would have resulted in preempting a strong pard rather than preempting opps).
Say you hold
AKQJxxxx-void -xx-xxx
You do not play SJS.
If you could, you would like to set trumps, and then verify via cuebids the controls in the minor suits, and finally use EKB
1D-1S (1)
2C-2H (2)
2NT-3S (3)
3NT- ??
1- I have time to set trump (!?!?!?)
2- I need 4sf cos 2S and 3S are both NF
3-now I have tld pard that I have long spades, but he does not know I have a selfsufficient suit. I would have bid the same even with AJxxxx-xx-Ax-Kxx, and this is wrong, wrong wrong, to bid the ame way these totally different hands
4- Now what do I bid ? Ideally I would have liked to check side controls and use EKB, but now I am stuck
====
Using SJS, you just set trumps, then use serious 3NT, cues, and RKCB/EKB to find the small/grand slam.
Quite a few times we were able to bid a grand thanks to the ability to set trumops early in the bidding (something that 4sf auction do not allow)
============================
I am sure, in practice as well as in theory.
And, yes, I use WJS even when opps are silent - and it is usually a good idea.
Unless your WJS hand hits a void in opener's hand, you're in the clear. You're in the contract you're most likely to end in anyway...
I play WJS as 2-5 HCP, concentrated into the bid suit if possible.
Imagine something like KJxxxx or QJxxxx after partner opens a minor. With this hand, you have two options only (if you don't play WJS)
1) bid 1M and on any partner's response bid 2M
2) pass and when opps reopen, reenter the bidding.
Either option gives opps chance to either hear more about your partner or to bid themselves.
The example is really nice, apart from the fact that your opps have a ton of hearts and forgot to interfere with your bidding :-). Also, your partner has shown good heart stoppers and no interest in spades. But, if you bid 4♠ over his 3NT, do you think that he will NOT get the message that you're interested in spade slam? Why would you bother with bidding FSF and 3♠ if you just wanted to blast into the game?
I admit that SJS do have some merits, of course, but on quite a lot of hands these can be worked around.
I can promise to start making notes about hands that could use SJS and see if we would be able to arrive in a better contract with SJS or without but I'm not going to just take your word for it . The merits of WJS are good enough for me not to get converted so easily