Revised Cappelletti response to 2Clubs bid How to resopnd holding both majors?
#1
Posted 2016-December-04, 17:56
#2
Posted 2016-December-04, 20:12
#4
Posted 2016-December-04, 20:53
#5
Posted 2016-December-04, 21:17
If so, it would depend on what various bids mean, but I would be comfortable guessing that 2H, 3H, and (possibly with a bit less comfort) 4H are all pass or correct without specific agreements.
#6
Posted 2016-December-05, 01:13
sfi, on 2016-December-04, 21:17, said:
If so, it would depend on what various bids mean, but I would be comfortable guessing that 2H, 3H, and (possibly with a bit less comfort) 4H are all pass or correct without specific agreements.
And 2NT would probably be a forcing enquiry, though I am not sure of what continuations would be best.
#7
Posted 2016-December-05, 04:22
#8
Posted 2016-December-05, 04:41
Vampyr, on 2016-December-05, 01:13, said:
If 2NT is a forcing relay, which is what it should be,then 3C and 3D by the cappeleti bidder will show the respective minor suit and then a relay of 3D/3H will ask for the major. To a 3D relay 3H/3S answer will show the respective major and to a 3H relay a 3S answer will show Spade suit and a 3NT answer will show a heart suit.
#9
Posted 2016-December-05, 12:37
msjennifer, on 2016-December-05, 04:22, said:
Advancer means the partner of the overcaller. Many of us misunderstood, because we were thinking that OP was interested in a defence, rather than help developing his own methods.
Lebensohl is a bit tricky when no anchor suit is known.
#10
Posted 2016-December-05, 14:42
You bid 2D when you prefer spades to hearts and 2H otherwise. That way, over 2D, overcaller can either rebid 2S (when spades are held) or 2H otherwise.
When advancer bids 2H, opener may pass with hearts or correct to 2S when not holding hearts.
The more interesting question is what does advancer bid when holding both majors and wanting to make a move toward game! Generally speaking, in such instances one bids 2NT.
#11
Posted 2016-December-05, 16:02
But this, where it does promise a major and a minor, I would follow Caitlynne's version - or I'd do something like the Woolsey trick (over X="4cM+longer minor, or various rare hands") where 2♦ is "show me the major" and then 2NT is "didn't like that one, show me the minor."