Jump reverse or not?
#1
Posted 2015-October-30, 07:14
♠KJxx
♥AK
♦AQ10xx
♣Qx
♠Ax
♥QJ10xxx
♦KJ
♣Axx
1♦ - 1♥
?
System 2-over-1 GF.
How the further bidding should look like?
#2
Posted 2015-October-30, 07:45
#3
Posted 2015-October-30, 08:39
Playing with a random partner with no agreements, uncertain whether 1♠ would be taken as forcing, 2♠ from N, 3♥ 4♥ all natural. South continues :
4NT 5♣ - ace ask; 0 or 3 (I assume 3041 is the standard default)
5♠ 5NT - K ask, as 5♦ would be Q ask, and 5♥ signoff; ♠K shown by NT as you must keep bidding below 6♥
6♥ - uncertain whether partner would take 6♦ as natural, or an SSA general try for heart grand.
With a partner you are familiar with then you will have your agreed methods.
#4
Posted 2015-October-30, 09:15
fromageGB, on 2015-October-30, 08:39, said:
4NT 5♣ - ace ask; 0 or 3 (I assume 3041 is the standard default)
5♠ 5NT - K ask, as 5♦ would be Q ask, and 5♥ signoff; ♠K shown by NT as you must keep bidding below 6♥
6♥ - uncertain whether partner would take 6♦ as natural, or an SSA general try for heart grand.
After 5NT, 6♣ should probably be an ask for the ♣K (with ♦K possibly also being useful) and 6♦ an ask for the ♦K. The trick playing SSAs here would be to make an SSA in diamonds instead of asking for kings. If partner has ♦AQxxx there are 3 discards and ♠K is unnecessary. Of course going that route does give up on the possibility of Opener holding both black kings so it is no guarantee of success. If SSAs are not being played then South can probably show ♦K plus the remaining 2 key cards and ♥Q, so that would be an alternative route to 7NT.
#5
Posted 2015-October-30, 09:30
fromageGB, on 2015-October-30, 08:39, said:
Playing with a random partner with no agreements, uncertain whether 1♠ would be taken as forcing, 2♠ from N, 3♥ 4♥ all natural. South continues :
4NT 5♣ - ace ask; 0 or 3 (I assume 3041 is the standard default)
5♠ 5NT - K ask, as 5♦ would be Q ask, and 5♥ signoff; ♠K shown by NT as you must keep bidding below 6♥
6♥ - uncertain whether partner would take 6♦ as natural, or an SSA general try for heart grand.
With a partner you are familiar with then you will have your agreed methods.
7♥ instead of 6 is rigth bid if you imagine North's worst possible hand. In real problem auction went:
1♦ - 1♥
2♠ - 3♥
3♠ - ?
North thought that 3♠ was a cue-bid and ♥ were agreed. South wasn't sure how to agree ♥
South has bid 6♥ and that became the final contract. Should North bid 7 with AK♥ A♦?
#6
Posted 2015-October-30, 09:48
mdaw, on 2015-October-30, 09:30, said:
1♦ - 1♥
2♠ - 3♥
3♠ - ?
North thought that 3♠ was a cue-bid and ♥ were agreed. South wasn't sure how to agree ♥
South has bid 6♥ and that became the final contract. Should North have bid 7 with these values: AK♥ A♦?
7NT is right and easy to bid whenever we find out that there are 13 tricks in hearts. 3♠ is not a cue bid but rather showing a very distributional (6-5) hand. North has 2 ways to agree hearts, namely 4♣ and 4♥. South on the other hand should not be in any hurry to agree hearts after 3♠ - why play in a potential 6-0 fit off the trump AK when there is a perfectly good 6-2 fit available in diamonds? It ended up a pretty messed up auction to be honest so be happy you at least got to a reasonable contract, most likely scoring with the field I would guess.
#7
Posted 2015-October-30, 10:26
mdaw, on 2015-October-30, 07:14, said:
♠KJxx
♥AK
♦AQ10xx
♣Qx
♠Ax
♥QJ10xxx
♦KJ
♣Axx
1♦ - 1♥
?
System 2-over-1 GF.
How the further bidding should look like?
I will try 2nt now
perhaps:
1d=1h
2nt=3h(checkback with only 5h)
4h=4s
4nt!=5d
5s=5nt
6d=7nt
4s-rkc in h
4nt=0-3
5d=KD grand try
5s=KS
5nt=anything else, deny KC
6d=QD
#8
Posted 2015-October-31, 06:28
♠KQJx
♥x
♦AKJ10xx
♣Ax
1♠ is enough for me on the thread hand. I can accept a 2NT rebid without totally agreeing with it.
#9
Posted 2015-October-31, 11:04
As for tv, screw it. You aren't missing anything. -- Ken Berg
I have come to realise it is futile to expect or hope a regular club game will be run in accordance with the laws. -- Jillybean
#11
Posted 2015-October-31, 15:02
Then after 3H - 4H, responder can BW and once all Key Cards are confirmed, with the great strength W has shown and the fitting cards in opener's first suit, 7NT stands out.
#12
Posted 2015-November-03, 02:11
(a) to protect the ♣Qx. Partner can still check back for a 4-4 spade fit. If the auction starts 1♦-1♥-2♠-3♣(4th suit forcing), what next? If you bid 3♥ and partner has ♣Axx or ♣Kxx, he probably won't risk 3♠ now and NT will be wrong sided.
(b) to describe the general strength of the hand (18-19). If you rebid 1♠ and partner passes, you'll be concerned that you may have missed game. If you rebid 2♠, it's fine to force to game if partner needs the traditional 6HCP to respond, but these days many people respond very light and it's nice to be able to stop in a contract you have a chance of making!
#13
Posted 2015-November-03, 09:17
Winner - BBO Challenge bracket #6 - February, 2017.
I rank
1. 2N = NAT. 18-19. Fairly descriptive.
2. 1♠ = NAT NF but rarely passed.
3. 2♠ = NAT. GF.
No idea how to bid 2/1. Perhaps on a very good day ...