jjbrr, on 2019-March-13, 20:17, said:
kenberg, re: reparations
I've never put much thought into reparations in this context. I suspect I won't put much more additional thought into it now that it's on my radar, unless media starts ramming it down our throats and I need to do my own research. It's a contributing factor to conflict, it is not the root cause. I understand both sides of the argument. I find myself agreeing with some points on both sides. It's a delicate situation.
Rather than calling it reparation, what if we called it investment in our collective future? Education reform, infrastructure improvement, equal rights? Are you still opposed to paying for it if they slap a different label on it? Before we start talking about reparations, why don't we talk about giving all Americans a fair roll of the dice? Let's talk about root cause.
I'll argue that your generation is a major contributor to the root cause, for a lot of reasons.
Changing the words that are used would not help. I favor "investment in our collective future", I very much favor it, but that leaves open the question of how this investment in our collective future is to take place. I very much favor education for example, and we no doubt need some investment in infrastructure. Presumably just about everyone favors equal rights even if they disagree whther some particular course of action does or does not promote equal rights. So: Yes to investment in our collective future. I favor it, I believe it would have broad support. No to reparations, I believe it will not have broad support.
It's not about phrasing, it's about how the money will be used. I am guessing that when you say "what if we called it..." you are not really suggesting that it is all about which words we use to describe one approach or the other. It's about what we choose to do.
As to generational arguments, I try to avoid them. It's true that I was born white and male, a citizen of the USA, and in 1939. Acknowledging that, I still favor investment in our collective future and I still oppose reparations.