Would you buy either of these?
#1
Posted 2013-March-01, 07:22
Would it be worthwhile to get Grant's version of 'Bridge Baron 2000' or 'Jack 5'?
#3
Posted 2013-March-01, 08:07
I had already DL'd that free software.
Honestly, I just checked some of these forums, and I'm surprised that there is not much activity here. I was looking closely at one particular thread, and noticed that the last post there was from @ 2 years ago... Do you know of other more active bridge forums?
#4
Posted 2013-March-01, 08:13
Rosewall, on 2013-March-01, 08:07, said:
I had already DL'd that free software.
Honestly, I just checked some of these forums, and I'm surprised that there is not much activity here. I was looking closely at one particular thread, and noticed that the last post there was from @ 2 years ago... Do you know of other more active bridge forums?
Couple quick comments
1. I own a copy of Jack. Can't recommend it highly enough
2. BBF is almost certainly the most active bridge forum out there. The only other one which comes close these days is bridgewinners. There are definiely some sub forums that don't see much activity, but the active sub forums are very active
#6
Posted 2013-March-01, 08:47
Considering that I'm a novice, would you get Grant's version of Bridge Master 2000 rather than Jack 5, or another bridge teaching/playing program first?
Thanks, guys... keep it coming.
#7
Posted 2013-March-01, 08:52
#8
Posted 2013-March-01, 10:27
I dont know Grants version of Bridge Master 2000, but I know Bridge Master, and I do know Jack (I own Jack 4).
Both programs serve different purposes, Bridge Master is teaching software, you get deals, which are like puzzels,
and you have to solve them, a finite number.
Jack is a Bridge playing program with unlimited deals, Jack has a teaching function, but this function is basically
a wake up call, do you remember that you should have done ...
If possible get both.
And try to find a regular partner to practice with, Bridge is a partnership game, the social acpect of the game is
very important.
With kind regards
Marlowe
Uwe Gebhardt (P_Marlowe)
#9
Posted 2013-March-01, 11:43
I would also recommend the BIL, they have mentors there, the website itself has plenty of articles, and you can meet someone through the website and the free lessons some of the people give.
"Learn from the mistakes of others. You won't live long enough to make them all yourself."
"One advantage of bad bidding is that you get practice at playing atrocious contracts."
-Alfred Sheinwold
#10
Posted 2013-March-01, 23:19
Jack is a game that lets you play with and against the computer. It's a strong player - but you can get almost as strong a player here if you're as cheap as I am: http://www.wbridge5.com/ - site is french, so direct download here: http://www.wbridge5....idge5_setup.exe
Personally I'get wbridge5 'cause it's free and plays a fairly 'standard' system with a strong no trump and 5 card majors, and consider buying BM2000 if you want.
#11
Posted 2013-March-02, 11:54
I'm in a dangerous, spendthrift mood the last few days, This means I'll probably get both Grant's version of Bridge Master 2000 and Jack 5. And I just DL'd and installed 'wbridge5'.
We will join BIL as well. It is so reasonably priced.
#12
Posted 2013-March-03, 08:12
Rosewall, on 2013-March-02, 11:54, said:
In that case there are a few pros who frequent these forums .. if you are interested in private lessons ..
-gwnn
#14
Posted 2013-March-05, 13:25
To make up for that I'll need to stay away from 'Panera Bread' for the rest of this month...
Thanks for all the input here. I'm looking forward to playing this game.
#15
#16
Posted 2013-March-05, 13:33
hrothgar, on 2013-March-03, 08:53, said:
Guaranteed cash flow. Highly motivated seller.
I think Wall Street already sold that, didn't they?
#17
Posted 2013-March-07, 07:48
Rosewall, on 2013-March-05, 13:25, said:
Good! And don't be shy at the forums either. Plenty of good advice to be had here in the B/N forum.
One bit of said advice - don't hesitate to post questions here about feedback you may get from other low to mid level players. There are a great many hacks who consider themselves quite sage, and are all too eager to dispense their advice/criticism, blissfully unaware of how wrong they often are. In my experience, bad feedback is one of the biggest hurdles in learning to play bridge well. So by all means, come get the straight dope from the real experts who post here.
Good luck and enjoy
-gwnn
#18
Posted 2013-March-07, 08:52
Cthulhu D, on 2013-March-01, 23:19, said:
Personally I'get wbridge5 'cause it's free and plays a fairly 'standard' system with a strong no trump and 5 card majors, and consider buying BM2000 if you want.
I have given up on wbridge5 I think - it has strange bugs. First I installed it under wine. It played fast but completely random, like opening 1NT with seven points and a void, that sort of things. Then I installed it on the same computer under windows 7. It played better but very slowly, and it once it let me play te opponents hand for the first four tricks and then swithched me back to the same seat I was in during the auction.
#19
Posted 2013-March-09, 19:01
Rosewall, on 2013-March-01, 07:22, said:
Would it be worthwhile to get Grant's version of 'Bridge Baron 2000' or 'Jack 5'?
Maybe you intend bridge master 2000. Don't buy it.
Wbridge5 is sometime better to jack and it is free.
Download double dummy solver it is free. and you may to look again at the hand that you have played in bbo. And see where you play wrong.
#20
Posted 2013-March-10, 13:17
It plays most system and conventions and you can tweak it as appropriate. I have it set up for 2/1 Advanced and play it mainly in teams mode. This gives you a good comparison for your bidding and play. You can also set it to double dummy. It also appears to defend quite well.
I'll probably get some flack for this but I have found playing with GIB helpful because you can see what all the bids mean. If you play in GIB tourneys you always get the best hand and play for North if they are declarer, which is good for practicing card play. The ability to review your scores at the end is very helpful as you can step through your opponents bidding and play to see how hey got their tops.